Just made three sigs related to spiderman... what do you guys think?

you're a graphic creating fool. I like em. too bad we don't play on marvel comic game servers.

I like the first the most second is too chaotic, even though I know Carnage is a chaotic character. The third one is good
Great job!

Now on a different forum I posted all three and they said they didn't like the first one at all cause of the hand coming out of the sig... I personally liked that feature... but then again they're the same people who liked that one assassin's creed sig better than my own.

i like the hand. gives the sig depth.

Fools!
Tha hand is great! (though the shadow on it has a different color than in the sig) because it enhances both the perspective of the original spiderman picture and the depth of the sig! Also the colors are well chosen- red and green are complementary colors. Also for those who know spiderman the background could have a meaning too- Symbiote trying to catch/take over Spiderman (not a fan of him myself but w/e)

Hope my comment was understandable and had some merit

Yes I understood it completely. Now while I didn't try and do the symbiote thing, the color scheme was planned. I had completely forgot about complimentory colors from art class until I looked at that sig tutorial that I posted... lol thanks everyone for your nice comments. This clan definetely has a better understanding of graphics design.

Stunning work, 1 and 3 look great, but little unsure what im seeing in 2.
you do graphics for a living or just picked up as you went along?

very good , you are crazy

lol graphics for a living? No sir I started out making skins for css a couple years ago using gimp... I then started attempting to make my own sigs... not even gonna show you what those looked like... I finally learned what an alpha channel was so I finally started doing some "nice" signatures...(not really nice at all...) And by the time I came to BK I was decent... but because of some great constructive critism from sinister and all the other graphics team members I finally was able to make a nice sig. So... it's taken a while...

Oh by the way dogshadow #2 is carnage... the other symbiote guy from spiderman. On the left hand side is his hand... and in the middle is his head... it was kinda supposed to look chaotic, but I may have overdone it a bit.