I would put Courtyard and Makin night in the rotation. After a fair trial period we could then decide if we should keep them in rotation. Also I would say that most people would like to set Asylum aside for a while. Many do not care for Seelow, however I still like that map.
i've never played makin night, dome, or courtyard. i've played makin day and not very fond of it plus i don't see it working very well for this kind of server. but do whatever and i'll play it and hopefully get a lot of kills on them.
Actually I m for removing asylum and leaving as is. All of the aforementioned choices and asylum and hanger (almost), facilitate camp/snipe from across the entire map. JMTCW.
CHill